Updates to our Terms of Use

We are updating our Terms of Use. Please carefully review the updated Terms before proceeding to our website.

Wednesday, March 27, 2024 | Back issues
Courthouse News Service Courthouse News Service

Flood of New Ghislaine Maxwell Docs Hit Public Record

More than a dozen files whose disclosure Ghislaine Maxwell fought bitterly to keep under wraps became public on Thursday morning, including a deposition in which prosecutors say she perjures herself.

MANHATTAN (CN) — More than a dozen files whose disclosure Ghislaine Maxwell fought bitterly to keep under wraps became public on Thursday morning, including a deposition in which prosecutors say she perjures herself.  

Quoted by prosecutors in her indictment, the April 2016 testimony shows Maxwell denying any knowledge of disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein’s sex-trafficking empire.  

“Did Jeffrey Epstein have a scheme to recruit underaged girls for sexual massages?” asked Sigrid McCawley, at the time an attorney for her prominent accuser Virginia Giuffre. “If you know.” 

“I don’t know what you are talking about,” Maxwell responded.   

Asked later to list all underaged individuals whom she encountered on Epstein’s properties, Maxwell responded four years ago: “I’m not aware of anybody that I interacted with, other than obviously [Ms. Giuffre] who was 17 at this point.” 

These denials form the basis of one of the two perjury charges that prosecutors leveled at Maxwell.  

The passage immediately preceding this exchange shows Maxwell’s dodging a question about Epstein’s sexual predilections. 

“So you don't know in your own mind that Jeffrey Epstein had a sexual preference for underage minors?” McCawley asked. 

Maxwell’s attorney Jeffrey Pagliuca attempted to object at the time, to no avail. 

“I cannot tell you what Jeffrey's story is,” Maxwell replied. “I'm not able to.” 

Maxwell’s other perjury count comes from a deposition from July 22, 2016, which is not among the documents released on Tuesday. Maxwell's other four charges accuse her of grooming underaged girls for Epstein’s predation.  

This deposition, and the 18 other files released today, come from the 2015 lawsuit where Giuffre called it defamatory for Maxwell to deny that she had been groomed as Epstein’s “sex slave.”   

The case had been sealed as part of a settlement, but the Miami Herald’s investigative reporter Julie K. Brown successfully sued to make the record public. Maxwell has alleged that their release could generate unflattering pretrial publicity that will compromise her right to a fair trial. 

Though lengthy deposition redacts the names of those not involved in the litigation, what has been revealed makes for grisly reading. 

When asked about hiring an underaged girl for Epstein, Maxwell replied: "No. I didn’t hire her, as I said, Jeffrey did.”

Maxwell remained silent about the girl’s age, only speaking on the topic of who hired her.

“Were you involved with sex between Jeffrey, [REDACTED] and yourself?” McCawley asked later, referring to the girl.

Federal prosecutors allege the Maxwell “participated” in sexual abuse of minors.

“Were you involved with sex between Jeffrey, [REDACTED] and yourself?” McCawley asked, referring to an underaged girl.  

Maxwell’s attorney Jeffrey Pagliuca then objected and instructed his client not to answer.  

“I’ve been instructed by my lawyer,” Maxwell replied.  

In another exchange, Maxwell is confronted about a laundry basket filed with sex toys at Epstein's Palm Beach house, and her attorney lodges a flurry of objections.  

“I don’t recollect anything about a laundry basket of sex toys,” Maxwell replied. 

There are more than a dozen mentions of sex toys in the 465-page deposition. 

“How would you describe sex toys?” McCawley asked Maxwell at one point. 

“I wouldn't describe sex toys,” she replied. 

After a brief back-and-forth, Maxwell’s testimony is redacted for a little more than two pages. The unsealed records triggered the disclosure of more than a dozen files citing them, including exhibits and legal briefings from attorneys for both Giuffre and Maxwell.

Before this morning, the last trove of files to be released showed an email correspondence between Maxwell and Epstein from January 2015 — the very existence of which contradicts a claim by Maxwell's attorneys that she had not been in touch with Epstein for more than a decade.

One 2015 email appears to contain a combative statement from Maxwell that slams the press and denies any participation in a sex-trafficking scandal.

Only Epstein had been the one sending the missive.

“Since JE was charged in 2007 for solicitation of a prostitute I have been the target of outright lies, innuendo, slander, defamation and salacious gossip and harassment,” Epstein wrote with credit to “GMax,” which prosecutors identified as a shorthand for Maxwell.

Under questioning by Giuffre’s attorney, Maxwell conceded a year later that the message was an unrealized public relations offensive.

“We made a statement, and then I was being advised to make an additional statement and I never did,” Maxwell said.

Those looking for bombshell political revelations in Maxwell’s testimony during an election year will be sorely disappointed. It was previously known that Giuffre claimed that Maxwell recruited her in President Donald Trump’s club Mar-a-Lago, back when the commander-in-chief was a private citizen.

The club’s name appears more than a dozen times in the deposition in that context, and little more is learned.

Former President Bill Clinton has long denied having visited Epstein’s private island in the U.S. Virgin Islands, and Maxwell vehemently rejects Giuffre’s claim that she saw the two of them there.

“This is a subject of defamation about Virginia and the lies she has told and one of lies she told was that President Clinton was on the island where I was present,” Maxwell said in 2016. “Absolutely 1,000 percent that is a flat-out total fabrication and lie.”

Today’s release does not end the yearslong open-records battle. Certain names remain redacted until the people behind the black lines have the opportunity to fight their future disclosure.

Categories / Criminal, Entertainment, Media

Subscribe to Closing Arguments

Sign up for new weekly newsletter Closing Arguments to get the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and hot cases and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world.

Loading...